PILL: Physical Internet Living Lab

2. The Physical Internet: a vision for the future of logistics

2.1 What is the Physical Internet

The logistics landscape today is riddled with challenges that hinder the seamless movement of goods between locations. Disruptions in the transport networks, unreliable planning, and a lack of transparency and collaboration between the many actors all lead to reduced operational efficiency.

“The paradigm change proposed through the Physical Internet is that logistics should be rethought as a system like the Digital Internet where networks would be interconnected through a common operating framework easing the breakdown of transport and handling loads. The Physical Internet allows progressively integrating currently dedicated logistics networks into a universally interconnected system.” - Montreuil, Meller & Ballot, 2010

In acknowledgement of this need for a more efficient and resilient logistics system, the European Commission has tasked the European Technology Platform on Logistics (also known as ETP Alice) to develop a strategic roadmap for the Physical Internet by 2040.

Video 1: The ETP Alice roadmap for the PI

2.2 State of PI

The ETP Alice roadmap has since inspired various European and regional research initiatives and projects, most of which are focused on either proving the socio-economic benefits of synchromodal operations or on researching the possibilities of automating vessels and infrastructure. The result is an at times fragmented landscape of projects with no holistic technological approach on how to design and build such an interconnected and synchromodal network of assets and stakeholders.

PILL seeks to bridge this gap by establishing a holistic technical framework into which the individual use cases can integrate. At its core, PILL envisions an open, decentralized framework for an interoperable and interconnected logistics network.

3. The PILL technical design

Our technical design or ‘Proof of Concept’ of an open Physical Internet network comprises of three design principles.

1. Network transparency
   All actors need to have -and contribute to- a holistic view of the entire logistics network with all its nodes, capabilities and transport.
   This transparency allows for optimum routing of transport.
    
2. Decentralised interoperability
   All actors are connected through a decentralised network, that enables trust. By following a set of standards, logistics processes on this network are fully interoperable, enabling automation across value chains.
    
3. Holistic, self-steering system
   All operations need to be self-steering and behave in a holistic way that maximally utilizes the available bandwidth of the system.
   This makes the system as efficient as possible, while increasing resilience against disruptions

3.1 The Network State: bringing transparency to the logistics network

One of the central goals of the Physical Internet is to enable transparency across the logistics network. The fundamental building blocks therefore required (nodes, capabilities and movers) were first outlined by Montreuil et al in their whitepaper Towards a Physical Internet: Meeting the Global Logistics Sustainability Grand Challenge (2010).

PILL’s contribution has been to (1) transform these building blocks into a standard for sharing logistics locations, services and capacity on an open network, and (2) consolidate the data into a virtual 2D map representing the entire logistics network: the Network State. By providing a holistic view of the logistics network to all participants, the Network State increases the discoverability and use of new nodes, routes or services.

The main advantages of this shared Network State are:

3.2 The PI-Client: Enabling interoperability on a decentralised network

Once a transparent network state is created, logistics actors can start cooperating on this logistics network. Since trusted collaboration is the pilar of the Physical Internet, collaboration should take place on a decentralised network. This PI network is grounded in the following four cornerstones:

• Open, decentralized network: Behavior & Governance rules for of a network for decentralized information sharing & interoperability.
• Standardised data model & processes: Data and process standards for logistics transport, expanding on the existing DCSA standard, rooted in the larger UN/CEFACT
• Universal PI-client connector: Software component that connects parties to the network & orchestrates interoperability between stakeholders.
• Routing engine & simulation model: Component responsible for the holistic calculation of the most optimum flow of goods, provider & mode agnostic.

The blueprint’s PI-client is the key driver of the decentralized logistics network.
First, it acts as a connector to the logistics PI network. When installed, it operates as a digital agent that links to all other PI-clients and shares information about the network state to and from each participant.

Second, the PI-client serves as a platform for 3^rd party applications and services:

1. It holds a marketplace for decentralised PI applications that enable supply chain processes or strategic optimisations.
2. It ensures that the different applications on the PI-network can interoperate with each other to automate and optimize processes.

3.3 PI Simulation: a holistic, self-steering system

To design and comprehend the essential attributes of a Physical Internet (PI) system, we have developed a simulation model. This tool acts as a safe, risk-free environment for experimenting with and validating various components of the PI system. Namely, route planning and booking, and resilience against disruptions.

Our simulation tool follows the agent-based modelling methodology, where independent entities are represented as agents. These agents are designed to interact dynamically with their surroundings, striving to achieve specific objectives. In this context, an agent symbolizes a transport asset, a logistics facility, and a logistics operator utilizing the logistics ecosystem.

4. Validation: building & testing the PI PoC

To validate our vision, three software components were developed that represented the first functional prototype of a decentralised PI-network:

• PI-Client: connects to the network, ensures interoperability with peers, and manages third-party applications.
• Network State Platform: provides visibility to the network and its data.
• PI simulation: simulates container flows over the proposed physical internet, producing detailed measurements

After developing and integrating these components into the proof-of-concept demo, a two-phase validation track was established to evaluate the effectiveness of the PoC in terms of:

• Improving the resilience of the network by evaluating its ability to withstand disruptions and find alternative solutions.
• Enabling interoperability between stakeholders and processes on a decentralized network;

4.1 Risk-free environment validation

The PI simulation tool, played a pivotal role in verifying the functionality and efficiency of the PoC's key components (booking & routing) at different scales. By simulating these processes on a greater scale, the tool provided invaluable insights into the operational feasibility and potential bottlenecks of the PI system, enabling us to built a scalable system.

Through simulation scenarios, comparing PI with the “Business as Usual” scenario, we quantified the improvements that the PI system could offer. By simulating both scenarios and analyzing the data, it was possible to draw clear comparisons in terms of efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and environmental impact. Our simulation experiments proved that a Physical internet, following our PoC, will optimise the flow of logistics in a way that significantly reduces emissions and improves asset utilisation. You can find a detailed view of our results in our final report (Sept 2024).

4.2 The PI-Client Living Lab 1: Network Discoverability

Two Living Labs were built of the PILL PoC, each validating an important part of the framework.

The first PI-Client Living Lab validated the overall interoperability of the PoC and impact of the Network Discoverability framework on transparency and planning efficiency.  The test consisted of a 2-week field test of the PI-client and the decentralised route planner. For this test, ten participants (forwarders, transporters and terminal operators) -who operate on the corridor of the Albert Canal (Antwerp)- installed the PI-client and used the route planner to create a network state. For the next two weeks, forwarders used the route planner to find and book available routes on the PI-network.

It was through this Living Lab test that the world’s first successful booking for a container on the Physical Internet was made.

It was through this Living Lab test that the world’s first successful booking for a container on the Physical Internet was made.

4.3 Implementation of PI: integrating the PI client in data spaces

With the PI-client, PILL has demonstrated the feasibility of interoperability on a decentralised network. To scale the Physical Internet to a commercial application, the PI-client must evolve into a plug-and-play solution adept at addressing all potential concerns about joining in and collaborating on a decentralised network. However, the current technology of creating a decentral, interoperable network still faces several scalability challenges, such as discoverability, identification and agreements.

These challenges align closely to the concerns being researched in the domain of “Data Spaces”, an emerging technology ecosystem centered on data sharing through decentralised networks. The similarities between data spaces and PI present an opportunity to combine both technologies and leverage the benefits of both Data Spaces and the Physical Internet.

In a second Living Lab, the PILL project joined together with the SYTADEL project to integrate the PI-client into the data space architecture of SYTADEL. The joint PILL-SYTADEL solution was a clear demonstration how information sharing according to the framework of Network discoverability (See chapter 3) could be achieved through a decentralised data space network. This solution was then tested through a joint Living Lab between PILL and SYTADEL. 

You can read about this test in the document PILL Living Lab Report which you can download below.

5. Future projects: beyond PILL

PILL has already made significant strides in advancing the ALICE roadmap and the State of the Art (SOTA) on the PI by:

• Building a framework for improved transparency in logistics nodes and services through the definition of a network state;
• Developing a decentralized network via a PI-client that enables interoperability across all nodes in the network;
• Addressing discoverability on a decentralized network by leveraging the foundations of data spaces.

By taking the first steps in integrating the PI in data spaces, PILL has established a first scalable framework and demonstrator of a Physical Internet. However, a key question remains unanswered.

Data spaces centre around data sharing technology. The primary concern in logistics, however, is ensuring the interoperability of processes and operations between participants. In many cases, data sharing is but a byproduct of the more crucial process sharing.

Creating a true PI data space therefore requires expanding the scope of data spaces to cover process sharing. As such, the PILL team is currently working on a follow-up project to build a process sharing framework for data spaces.

For deeper insights into process sharing, refer to this paper by research institute TNO.

6. The PI-blueprint: a vision for implementing the physical internet

The main outcome of PILL is the definition of a blueprint for a Physical Internet implementation framework, based on the key criteria discussed on this page. The PI-Blueprint document is the accomplishment of 3 years of research and validation.

The key research question that this blueprint tries to answer is the following:

What is needed to establish a trustworthy full-stack Physical Internet that allows stakeholders (1) to connect seamlessly and effortlessly, (2) to publish and discover logistics services, (3) to agree on the conditions of said services and to (4) automatically exchange the execution status of the pre-agreed process, while (5) seamlessly integrating with connected processes?

Download the PI-blueprint

Besides the PI-Blueprint PILL also resulted in various other outcomes. Such as a trust framework for a logistics data space governance and the impact study of running logistics processes on an Agent-Based Simulation model.
The deliverables are grouped in 5 categories. In the download below titled “PILL deliverables – Full overview”, you find a clear overview and explanation of all deliverables per category.

• Market research
  All market and literature research around Physical internet
• Pi-Framework Architecture
  Our PI-blueprint and further details about the PI Architecture.
• Agent-based model research
  All research and testing concerning the impact of operating logistics processes on an Agent-based model.
• Living Labs & ABM testing & building
  An overview of our Living Lab tests, as well as frontend and backend  demo’s of all POCs.
• Academic research
  A summary of all academic journals and conference papers published during the PILL project, concerning the setup of the trust framework.

All deliverables of PILL can be downloaded here.

Additionally, all PILL POC components are openly available for anyone to start exploring.
If you are interested in receiving our PILL POC components, please contact our lead PILL developer:

Contact: alper.basak@imec.be